Showing posts with label Michael Pearl. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Michael Pearl. Show all posts

Monday, September 9, 2013

Weeds in your child's flower garden

I was weeding yesterday and it struck me that the way you remove weeds is evidence in the Creation that spanking kids isn't God's way...

(I know...what ELSE would I be thinking about, right!?) :)



Anyone who has ever planted flowers knows that if you're trying to grow a nice garden of flowers you can expect that weeds will come. Why, though? Is it because there is something wrong with the flowers? Something wrong with the soil? Is there something about them that causes weeds to appear? No. We all know that it has nothing to do with the flowers but that it's the tenaciousness of weeds and the nature of the world that makes it so that if there is dirt...there will be weeds. 

The presence of weeds indicates nothing "wrong" with the flowers...only testifies to the "power" of the weeds and the things that help weeds spread...




With our children, obviously we are trying to grow a "beautiful garden" in their character. And, the fact that "weeds" pop up is likewise not some confirmation that there is something "wrong" with the children...as in that they were born with sin in them. 

The presence of "weeds" in humans says something not of the nature of humans...but of the nature of sin. (so powerful are these "weeds" that humans attract that the biggest strongest warrior in the Universe had to come and battle them because humans couldn't do it themselves!)

So, when a child enters this world and you begin planting a garden (good morals, manners, and habits) in them you can expect that weeds will come. And, those weeds (bad behavior) will show up and start to grow for the same reasons they do in nature. Seeds are carried and distributed by living creatures, by the wind, and by creeping roots.




And, see...even the most well-intentioned parent is going to "carry weed seeds" and drop them in their child's "garden." Then, there are neighbors. Friends at daycare and Sunday School. TV. Weed seeds are everywhere and if your child's "soil" is such that flowers are able to grow, then so can weeds. And, again, it is not because something is wrong with the child or the child's soil that these weeds appear...it is because of the nature of the weeds and soil that makes it possible for weeds to appear and begin to grow.


Weeds (bad behavior and attitudes) ruin the appearance of our lovely gardens (children). And, not only that but they can choke the flowers (take over and turn your child into a delinquent!) and need to be removed. This is why we discipline our children.



ROMANS 1:18-20

For the wrath of God is revealed from heaven against all ungodliness and unrighteousness of men who suppress the truth in unrighteousness, because that which is known about God is evident within them; for God made it evident to them.

For since the creation of the world His invisible attributes, His eternal power and divine nature,have been clearly seen, being understood through what has been made, so that they are without excuse!


So, how do we remove weeds from a literal flower garden? Remember that the design of Creation is no accident. Because of the unreliability of storytelling (Paul Bunyan tales, Whisper Down the Lane), and even the outright attempts to mis-interpret scripture, God has left evidence in the Creation that cannot be altered...because the truth matters and He loves us enough to make sure there's a way to know it that can't be corrupted. These truths are part of the natural and unchanging way that the physical universe works and it's there to teach us things we actually already know...because the truth is on our hearts because God put it there...

When approaching a weedy garden, your goal is.. to remove the weeds without harming the flowers and hopefully in such a way as to prevent the weeds from returning.


ATTACKING THE FLOWERS




Say you approached "weeding" by whacking the flowers? You would do nothing to get rid of the weeds, would you? Attacking the flowers would only make the weeds stronger, and the flowers weaker and less beautiful. 


Attacking the weeds with too much zeal and force also will attack the flowers...as sometimes the roots are intertwined it will pull the flowers out, too. And, you can end up grabbing the flowers by mistake and uprooting them or tearing the plants.


Punishing children involves inflicting some sort of pain on them. The whole reason our body perceives pain is to alert it that something is harming/hurting/damaging it. Purposefully causing some sort of pain to the child is like harming/hurting/damaging the flowers, which obviously, would not do the flowers any good nor protect them from weeds.


Likewise, purposefully inflicting pain on our children (flowers) will not have any negative effect on "weed" growth. On the contrary, it can actually enhance "weed growth" in their gardens...


Ephesians 6:4
Fathers, do not provoke your children to anger, but bring them up in the discipline and instruction of the Lord.


It's really hard to have pain inflicted on you purposefully without feeling anger...and as modern science has revealed to us: anger destroys us. It's why God warned us not to do it... 



PULLING OUT THE LEAVES




If you approached "weeding" by simply pulling out what's visible...you would not actually be removing the weeds...just the visual evidence that they are there.


Dollar weeds, for example, are growing all over my flower gardens and in my yard. If I just reach in and grab at them and yank the leaves, they come off...not out. If I yanked off all the leaves, when I would be done, I could leave the garden appearing "weed free." My friends and neighbors might even look and say, "Well, what a beautiful weed-free garden you have!" But, underneath, the actual weed would be completely unaffected and would continue to grow and flourish and choke the roots of the flowers.


When the weeds of bad behavior appear in your child's garden, you can approach it by spanking the child. This will get you immediate results. You will look at your child's "garden" and you will no longer see them back-talking, biting, hitting other kids, or doing whatever outward behavior that was "weeding up their garden". Just like my garden where I tore out the leaves of the dollar weeds, many people will look at your child and say, "What a well-behaved child you have!" But, just like the real garden, all you did was remove the visual evidence of the weeds...and those roots are still growing...and quietly choking out the garden (your child).


IMPORTANCE OF THE VISUAL EVIDENCE

What if...a weed...once the leaves were removed...never re-grew leaves but would continue to grow and choke out the flowers? This would be a grave concern to serious gardeners because if you can't see an "enemy" you can't fight it! This...is what parents who spank are doing...and normally with all the weed's leaves torn away (the child's spirit broken into submission) it takes until the child is in their teens until the evidence of that weedy root system growing and choking the flowers' roots reappears.


(Sadly, even then, parents dismiss this as "typical teenage rebellion" and believe these teenage "weeds" to be newly grown. Our culture is so far far removed from the truth about children that most parents have no clue that they are their own garden's worst enemy!)


PROPER WEEDING


The only way to actually remove a weed from your garden is to gently pull on it. 



Matthew 11:29
Take My yoke upon you and learn from Me, for I am gentle and humble in heart, and you will find rest for your souls.

When I first moved to Florida and first found these particular weeds in my garden I was unfamiliar with them and did actually just pull out the leaves, until one day when I did it gently and I realized that they were all connected! Then, I learned that by gently pulling on these dollar weeds and pulling away some of the surrounding dirt, this long intricate path that these roots take is revealed and all comes out! After this revelation, to pull too harshly on a leaf and get...just the leaf in my hand...was very frustrating! And, then, because I'd yanked too hard, I'd have to get my fingers dirty and dig to get at the roots. 

As a former spanker, I can tell you that I have had this same revelation in my parenting. I once did address just the visual evidence of "weeds" in my children's gardens...and I spanked them away. Then, when I realized that there were these intricate paths of interconnected roots that I could reveal if I just "pulled gently"...it changed everything. And, now, the times that I am "too harsh" and see a "weed" and just barge in and yank it out...I realize with frustration what I've just done and then...I "have to get my hands dirty" and dig. 


Sometimes, when weeding, as you tug you realize that the root path goes right through one of your flower's roots and you must jiggle it and move it around gently to remove it from the flower. All of this means something to us as parents and these lessons were left in the Creation for us by God so that we would learn and no one would deceive us... 







ROMANS 1:18-20
For the wrath of God is revealed from heaven against all ungodliness and unrighteousness of men who suppress the truth in unrighteousness, because that which is known about God is evident within them; for God made it evident to them.

For since the creation of the world His invisible attributes, His eternal power and divine nature,have been clearly seen, being understood through what has been made, so that they are without excuse!



PERSISTENCE


Any gardener knows, too, that you don't just weed your flower garden once and done. Jesus came to save us not from hell...but from sin, and sin isn't going away anytime soon. Paul referred to salvation as a process saying he was saved, is being saved and will be saved from sin. The Gardener is always there "saving us" from our sins and will continue to do so weeding our gardens every day if we let Him.


There are seeds and roots of it everywhere in our world. As long as there are gardens, sin will be crouched at our doors ready to consume us, right? Weeds will keep coming and a loving gardener will keep them in check.

God left us this evidence in Creation because it's there, in plain sight, for all to see. To choose to believe teachers like Michael Pearl, Gary Ezzo, Ted Tripp and James Dobson and others like them...is to evoke the wrath of God because...



ROMANS 1:18-20
...the wrath of God is revealed from heaven against all ungodliness and unrighteousness of men who suppress the truth in unrighteousness, because that which is known about God is evident within them; for God made it evident to them.

For since the creation of the world His invisible attributes, His eternal power and divine nature,have been clearly seen, being understood through what has been made, so that they are without excuse!







All of the following verses apply to all of us with all others...which means they apply to you and your relationship with your children also...

(If you read these verses below and find yourself saying, "Yeah, but..." then you really need to re-read that Romans 1 quote again...and again...and again...and then re-read these verses again...and again...and again...until you lose those buts...)

James 3:17
But the wisdom from above is first pure, then peaceable, gentle, reasonable, full of mercy and good fruits, unwavering, without hypocrisy.

James 3:13
Who among you is wise and understanding? Let him show by his good behavior his deeds in the gentleness of wisdom.


Matthew 5:5
“Blessed are the gentle, for they shall inherit the earth."

1 Peter 3:15
...sanctify Christ as Lord in your hearts, always being ready to make a defense to everyone who asks you to give an account for the hope that is in you, yet with gentleness and reverence...

Titus 3:2

...malign no one, to be peaceable, gentle, showing every consideration for all men.

2 Timothy 2:25

...with gentleness correcting those who are in opposition, if perhaps God may grant them repentance leading to the knowledge of the truth

1 Timothy 6:11
But flee from these things, you man of God, and pursue righteousness, godliness, faith, love, perseverance and gentleness.

1 Peter 3:3-5

Your adornment must not be merely external—braiding the hair, and wearing gold jewelry, or putting on dresses; but let it be the hidden person of the heart, with the imperishable quality of a gentle and quiet spirit, which is precious in the sight of God. For in this way in former times the holy women also, who hoped in God, used to adorn themselves, being submissive to their own husbands;

2 Corinthians 10:1
Now I, Paul, myself urge you by the meekness and gentleness of Christ...

Galatians 5:23But the fruit of the Spirit is love, joy, peace, patience, kindness, goodness, faithfulness, gentleness, self-control; against such things there is no law.

Galatians 6:1

Brethren, even if anyone is caught in any trespass, you who are spiritual, restore such a one in a spirit of gentleness; each one looking to yourself, so that you too will not be tempted.

Ephesians 4:2
...walk in a manner worthy of the calling with which you have been called with all humility and gentleness, with patience, showing tolerance for one another in love, being diligent to preserve the unity of the Spirit in the bond of peace.

Philippians 4:5
Let your gentle spirit be known to all men. The Lord is near.



Thursday, February 28, 2013

Training kids like dogs: Discipline by example

The most automatic argument I've ever received from people when the discussion of "not spanking/punishing" kids comes up is, "How will kids learn if you don't give them consequences." 

I wrote a post one day about how "it's true that we do need to train children just like Michael Pearl says: like dogs." When training a dog to respect the boundary of an invisible electric fence that process is like this with dogs:

1.
clearly show the boundary
2. establish the safe zone by the owner showing praise and comfort when moving away from the boundary
3. allow the dog to experience the consequence of crossing the line and feeling the pain caused by that line being crossed
4. be there to comfort and praise to the dog when the dog rushes toward the safety of the owner and home

And, this process would almost suggest that this is true...that we need negative consequences to learn boundaries. But, while negative consequences do teach us where some boundary lines are, there is another way to learn that involves no pain and is just as effective...Romans 1 says so because I saw it demonstrated in the Creation just the other day!

The belief in the need for the experience of negative consequences sorta' goes hand-in-hand with that belief that ya can't appreciate good without bad and so on. I have never bought into that because everything God created was good and I can't believe that God created us that we must experience that which nailed Him to the cross in order to appreciate that! 


So, one day I was out in my yard planting...and planting...and planting! ;) And, the dogs started to bark as a jogger was going past...and I noticed something...something really cool that I had suspected and finally saw the fruit...and fortunately had my phone with me to take a picture!

We have three dogs. Two of them have been trained as outlined above with the shocking collars to respect the boundary of the underground electric fence. The newbie, a Chihuahua puppy which joined our family in November...has never been trained, but, has always gone outside with the other dogs...and look what he learned...without ever receiving a negative consequence...


You can see where the boundary is, can't you? The dog in the background (left) is Jasmine. She's been officially trained with the electric collar and has had some pretty painful shocks. The cutie in the foreground of the photo is the newbie who has never been shocked. How did he learn the boundary?

By modeling. By example. When running with the pack the puppy stays inside the safe zone. It's the coolest thing to see him standing there barking as tho' he can't cross that line! But, another interesting note is that sometimes the puppy will cross the boundary...if the other dogs are not around. 

So, what does that tell you about parenting? We so often wonder why our kids misbehave and do this n' that...but how much time do we really spend with our children being the example? Modeling for them how to behave and not "cross boundaries" in this world? How much time do our kids spend with each other, with other kids, or alone? How much time do we really invest into modeling and being the example for them?

Do we always say please and thank-you to them?
Do we always be quiet when they are sleeping?
Do we always ask them "permission" before taking a toy out of their hands?
Do we always listen and respond to our children when they speak to us?
Do we always speak respectfully to our spouse in front of the children?
Do we put our cart away at the grocery store? (sorry! Pet peeve of mine had to add it!)
Do we decide at random that "it's time to go" and make our kids leave a friend's house when there is still 20 minutes to go on the movie they're watching?
Do we snap at them and tell them to leave us alone because "we're in the middle of an important status update on Facebook?"
Do we tell the kids it's bath time "right now" when they're in the middle of an exciting video game?
Do we hit (spank) our children to get them to do what we want (listen to us)?

Do we model disrespectful and selfish behavior to our children and then wonder why THEY misbehave? I can't tell ya how many times I have been in public and heard parents snapping at their kids or hitting/spanking them and just overall treating the child totally disrespectfully...because their child just did something...disrespectful. (Or, how many times I've heard myself speaking disrespectfully to my kids and yelling at them for being disrespectful to each other. And, it always hits me when I ask the inevitable, "WHY did you just say that to your sister!") The irony is too sad. The most ironic and saddest is the child who is hit (spanked) because they just hit someone...

Truth is if you listen to your kids speak to each other...they sound just like you. The way they speak to you is a reflection of how you speak to them. They are following your example. Kids raised in a punitive environment will know that if they say "this or that" that you will hit/spank them and alter what they say/do for to avoid punishment, but, what's inside of them how to treat others is the example you've set. And, so sad it is that they get punished for what we have taught them...


"A good tree cannot produce bad fruit, nor can a bad tree produce good fruit." 
Matthew 7:18

The tree (parent) needs to be good for the fruit (children) to be. If the fruit (child's behavior) is bad...the problem isn't the fruit...it's the tree (parent's example.) 

Jesus was without sin, and He said that He only did what He saw the Father doing...and that seeing Jesus we were seeing the Father.

Our kids do what they see us do and seeing our children...we see ourselves.

This should be life-alteringly convicting to the truth-loving Christian...

If the kids are naughty something is wrong with the model they are following. And, Christians should not be so blind to this as they are when it is their leader who designed us this way and told us this Himself!! Focusing on controlling, punishing, and changing the fruit isn't character building in the children...but only hides your own failings and sin...and maybe that gives us a clue where this type of parenting is really founded?

So, getting back to Michael Pearl and his advice that training kids is like training a dog...OK! Yes! Mr. Pearl! You're right! You can actually even be a dog and train a dog! You don't even have to have any brains to do it! You can simply set the example with your own life...and your children will learn right from wrong and where all the "boundaries" are in life without ever being hit, hurt, or punished. It's true! 

(Mr. Pearl really needs to start watching "The Dog Whisperer" if ya ask me!!!)


I guess we can learn about parenting from cats, too ;)


Sunday, December 23, 2012

Michael Pearl is right about training kids like dogs!

I was just thinking about pain...and it's usefulness in "training children."

People seem to think that this is the way to train kids. They do something you dislike so you give them pain and they'll be enlightened and never do that thing again. Authors like Michael Pearl have even likened training kids to training dogs and mules. 

Now, we have an invisible fence around our property for our dogs. This fence gives them (and us) a lot of freedom. But, to enjoy that freedom they had to learn the boundaries of the fence and that took some training. First they had to be shown the boundary (via flags). They had to be led toward the boundary and then rushed back toward the house and praised. (they had to learn that going toward the house is good and pleasurable!) Then, they had to be introduced to the shocking collar and allowed to experience what happens when they cross the boundary.

If one were to compare training kids to training dogs this would seem to be an obvious clear-cut example of the value of spanking. 

Dog learns where the boundary is.
Dog learns that crossing that line = pain.
Dog learns that escape from that pain = move toward the owner and home.

Hmmm.

So, how is this parallel to spanking? 
Let's see...

Baby learns where boundary is...
"Don't touch the knick-knacks on the coffee table!"
Baby learns that crossing that line = pain.
Mom hits baby's hand.
Baby learns that escape from that pain = move toward...um...mom? who just hit baby and was the source of the pain? 
Wait a minute.

Something must be wrong with my example. We'll try another...

Kid learns where boundary is...
"Don't run out into the street!"
Kid learns that crossing that line = pain.
Mom or dad whacks kid on hiney to cause pain.
Kid learns that esape from that pain = move toward...um...mom or dad who...um...just were the source of the pain.

Something's not working!

Why don't we try starting from the kid example and apply it to training the dog on the fence! Let's try it that way!

Dog learns where boundary is...
Dog is "told not to cross the boundary" in doggy language...basically shown the boundary flags by owner and pulled back from the flags to indicate "stay away from those."
Dogs learns that crossing that line = pain
Dog is allowed to cross line and the collar gives him a zap!
Dogs learns that escape from that pain = run toward the source of the pain

Wait. 
Again. 
This is not working.

In training the dog the consequence of crossing the boundary = pain and the owner and home are the escape from the pain of that. 
In the way people (like Michael Pearl and James Dobson) train kids...the home is the source of the pain.
This is not correlating at all. This is not making any sense.

Maybe we have the dog training part messed up? Maybe that's why this is not working?

What if to train the dog on the invisible fence we did it this way:
Teach dog where boundary is
Teach dog that crossing boundary = pain
Teach dog that escape from the pain = run toward owner and house 
Teach dog that owner scolds and punishes dog after retreating from crossed boundary

That way now it would be just like how we train kids...
Teach kid where boundary is...
Teach kid that crossing boundary = pain...
Teach kid that...after crossing boundary...to run to parents to receive punishment, scolding (more pain) 

When you look at it this way is should look as wrong and silly as it is because you know what would happen to a dog trained like this! 
(And, I would dare say God designed dogs this way to show us this truth!) 

We all know that if we scold and punish the dog when it's retreating from the zapping from the fence that all it would do would be to confuse the dog. The dog would never make sense of his world and would never understand that boundary or its consequences...ever!

So, maybe Michael Pearl is right?
Maybe training kids is just like training a dog?
He just doesn't apparently seem to understand how to train a dog...

If the true process to train a dog to stay within the boundary of the invisible fence is to do the following things...how would you do this with your child?
1. clearly show the boundary
2. establish the safe zone by the owner showing praise and comfort when moving away from the boundary
3. allow the dog to experience the consequence of crossing the line and feeling the pain caused by that line being crossed
4. be there to comfort and praise to the dog when the dog rushes toward the safety of the owner and home

In the training of a dog...the owner is not the source of the pain. The crossing of the boundary is. 

The dog clearly sees this because the pain always comes from the crossed boundary and the pleasure and safety always comes from the owner. A dog so trained will never get zapped by that fence again...and will never cower or run from the owner, for that matter. Trained this way the owner and home are unquestionably a source of safety and comfort that the dog learns to run toward for the relief of his pain and fear. 

The dog is safer because of this and everyone has more freedom and joy in life and in the relationship between owner and dog.

A child who would be trained this way...the way we train a dog...would learn where boundaries are and what the consequences are of crossing those boundaries AND the child would learn to always run to the parent when they are in trouble.

Imagine! Imagine a world where kids run to parents when they've done something wrong and look to their parents for help?!

Imagine a world where kids know their parents are always there for them to help them no matter what trouble they get into?

Imagine kids who don't try to hide their mistakes because they know the best way to get out of the pain that mistake's caused is to run to the parent?

If only people would train kids the way they train dogs!!!

Instead we live in a world where...people don't train their children the way they'd train a dog. We live in a world where well-meaning Christian parents are teaching their children that when they cross a boundary that the parent is a source of pain.

Well-meaning parents are teaching their children to run from that which God has designed them to find safety and refuge in: them. 

Well-meaning parents are therefore teaching their children by extension then to run from God, as well. 

In the world that spanked kids live in they don't fully comprehend true consequences and they fear pain from all sides. Nothing is safe.

So, what to do?

If a baby is too little to comprehend the consequence of handling and possibly breaking knick-knacks...they should be moved. If they are old enough to understand the true consequence of breaking something someone cares about then the pain they would feel at ruining something someone cares about should be the pain they want to avoid...not the pain of being hit by a parent.

Kids should fear running out into traffic because of the fear of the pain of being struck by a car not because they fear being struck by a parent.

All boundaries have consequences if they're crossed. It's our job as parents to teach kids that we are the source of safety, comfort, and relief from the pain those crossed boundaries bring upon them...and by extension then that God is that source of safety and refuge. 

If what our children learn to fear is us, then...they will never truly comprehend what the true source of pain is from the consequences of their actions...and what kids will end up running from will be home...to the point that they'll be willing to cross painful boundaries and get "zapped" to get away from us...

When in this world we children (of God) mess up and "cross boundaries" and are in pain from the consequences of those choices...we all want to run to God, "Save me!" 

This is how our children should see us...a source of salvation from their pain. 

When a kid "crosses a boundary" and a dad says to the kid, "Get over here!" And, that kid thinks about "what he's got coming to him..." it should be something the kid wants and craves not fears.

- - -

ROMANS 1:18-20
...that which is known about God is evident within them; for God made it evident to them.

For since the creation of the world His invisible attributes, His eternal power and divine nature, have been clearly seen, being understood through what has been made, so that they are without excuse.



Which type of parent are you when your child's done something wrong?









Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...